Finding Gold for Management Letters

One simple step can provide you with loads of great ideas

We auditors love to provide extra value to our clients. How? Many times we do so in management letters.

But have you ever come to the close of your audit and had no ideas? Maybe you’ve heard your audit team say, “hey, what should we include in the management letter?” A better alternative would be to hear, “man, I have so many great recommendations, I’m not sure which to use.” Having numerous ideas is a possibility if we know where to look.

Nuggets of gold lie along our audit path. But how do we find them?

finding gold for management letters

Picture is courtesy of DollarPhotoClub.com.

I’m not sure why, but many companies do not ask their employees for new ideas. If they did, they might find a goldmine. So if management isn’t digging up those particular elements, shouldn’t we? (And you can do so with one easy step.)

While performing walkthroughs (a risk assessment procedure performed early in the audit), ask each interviewee, “if you had a magic wand and could wave it over your department, what one thing would you change?” You’ll get great ideas, and the person providing the information will be glad that someone is listening to and valuing their ideas. Then summarize those nuggets of wisdom in your audit file (near the location of your management letter). While you may not use every suggestion, assay each thought and consider it’s value. 

Doesn’t it make sense that my client’s staff would possess better ideas than me? After all, they are there every day, and many have worked with the client for years. I’m only there a few days, so my inside knowledge is limited. By asking for my client’s ideas, I am just tapping into the latent knowledge and expressing it in the management letter.   

Try this, and I promise, you’ll strike gold.

Learn from the CPA Scribo newsletter!

Get my free weekly accounting and auditing digest with the latest content.

Powered by ConvertKit

Please note: I reserve the right to delete comments that are offensive or off-topic.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

4 thoughts on “Finding Gold for Management Letters

  1. The big accounting firms have caught flak for letting the consulting part of their business become so prominent, but it seems natural for auditors to provide value based on what they learn from the audit. And you’re not charging a fee for this advice, so there doesn’t seem to be an independence concern. It sounds like great advice!

    • Eddie, yes, I do think auditors should be mindful of possible independence issues, but if the auditor stays away from making management decisions, the recommendations are a nice byproduct of the audit process. Thanks for your comment.